All-AFL Teams
2003
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Rookie Team |
| QB | Peyton Manning, Washington | Daunte Culpepper, Albuquerque | Byron Leftwich, Cleveland |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Brunswick | Ahman Green, Tempe | Domanick Davis, Brunswick |
| LaDainian Tomlinson, Washington | Clinton Portis, Fremont | Onterrio Smith, Orlando | |
| WR | Randy Moss, Albuquerque | Torry Holt, Brunswick | Anquan Boldin, Orlando |
| Chad Johnson, Minnesota | Hines Ward, Tempe | Charles Rogers, Cleveland | |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Fremont | Shannon Sharpe, Minnesota | Teyo Johnson, Free Agent |
| K | Mike Vanderjagt, Minnesota | Jeff Wilkins, Orlando | Josh Brown, K, Blue Ridge |
| D/S | Tampa Bay, Dakota | Miami, Brunswick |
2002
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Rookie Team |
| QB | Jeff Garcia, Dakota | Donovan McNabb, Rocky Mountain | David Carr, Smokey Mountain |
| RB | Priest Holmes, Brunswick | Duece McAllister, Tempe | Clinton Portis, Fremont |
| Ricky Williams, Albuquerque | Charlie Garner, Blue Ridge | William Green, Tempe | |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Rocky Mountain | Peerless Price, Dakota | Dante' Stallworth, Smokey Mountain |
| Marvin Harrison, Tempe | Eric Moulds, Cleveland | None | |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Brunswick | Todd Heap, Albuquerque | Jeremy Shockey, Tempe |
| K | David Akers, Albuquerque | Sebastian Janikowski, Tacoma | Matt Bryant, Fremont |
| D/S | Tampa Bay, Rocky Mountain | Oakland, Albuquerque |
2001
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Rookie Team |
| QB | Jeff Garcia, Piscataway | Kurt Warner, Fremont | Chris Weinke, Washington |
| RB | Marshall Faulk, Washington | Curtis Martin, London | LaDainian Tomlinson, Tacoma |
| Priest Holmes, Brunswick | Ricky Williams, Smokey Mountain | Anthony Thomas, London | |
| WR | Terrell Owens, Manila | Randy Moss, Brunswick | Chris Chambers, Tempe |
| Marvin Harrison, London | David Boston, Washington | D. Terrell/K. Robinson, Tacoma | |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Brunswick | Frank Wycheck, Piscataway | Alge Crumpler, Fremont |
| K | Jason Elam, Brunswick | Sebastian Janikowski, London | Jose Cortez, Manila |
| D/S | Philadelphia, Smokey Mountain | St. Louis, Tacoma |
2000
| Position | First Team | Second Team | Rookie Team |
| QB | Peyton Manning, Universal City | Jeff Garcia, Manila | None |
| RB | Edgerrin James, Danville | Robert Smith, Piscataway | Mike Anderson, Tempe |
| Marshall Faulk, British | Charlie Garner, Piscataway | Jamal Lewis, Fremont | |
| WR | Rod Smith, London | Marvin Harrison, Manila | Sylvester Morris, Brunswick |
| Randy Moss, London | Isaac Bruce, Piscataway | Travis Taylor, Universal City | |
| TE | Tony Gonzalez, Brunswick | Shannon Sharpe, Fremont | Bubba Franks, Tempe |
| K | Matt Stover, Tempe | Olindo Mare, London | Sebastian Janikowski, Orlando |
| D/S | Miami, Manila | Tampa Bay, Fremont |